I feel terrible even saying this.
But having a cat who seems to have developed habit of pissing outside of the litter box is taking a lot of the joy out of being a cat owner. (And if you're not interested in cats' toilet habits, I suggest you click away right now!)
I've known a number of people who've had problems with cats who, well, couldn't think inside the box, and when they'd say things like, "I don't know how long I can put up with this - I don't want to get rid of the cat, but this is just intolerable," I'd never say anything, but a little part of me would think, what an awful cat parent! How could they ever want to get rid of their cat for such a reason??
Well, mea culpa, for now I understand your pain. There's no way I'm getting rid of anyone, but I can understand the temptation.
In his declining years, Eldest Cat has occasionally gotten a little confused and used a convenient pile of clothes or towels or bed linens instead of the box - hey, if it's squishy and diggable-in, it'll serve the purpose! But we recognize our complicity in this (the first time it happened was when he spent one afternoon shut in the bedroom by accident), and try not to leave piles of soft things on the floor to tempt him, and it's pretty rare. (It's also not so terrible because - and wow, I can't believe I'm telling you all this - he has amazingly odorless pee. You really have to take a close sniff of something to figure out if he's had an accident on it or not.)
The current problem is different, however, because it happens when someone (okay, Middle Cat) tries to pee right up against the front wall of the box, and misses. (The boys pee at the back of the box, and she pees at the front. Do not ask how I know this.) For the moment, it's a pain in the ass but tolerable, because we have the box in the second bathroom, on the tiled floor, and the clean-up, while annoying as all get out (because we use clumping litter, which gets scattered all over the floor, and funnily enough, clumps when it gets wet! ugh!) is pretty easy. In this way only, though, I'm dreading the move to the new apartment, because the box is going to go in a closet - on the hardwood floor, and cat piss can soak through the boards (or down the cracks in the boards) to take up permanent residence in your floor. So. Not. Good. (Yes, we're going to get a tray to put under the box - I want to get one of those trays you put out for people to shed winter shoes and boots onto, which is supposed to hold all the grit and melting snow and so on. I want to get the BIGGEST one I can find. But I still worry. If any of you have any magic solutions, I'd love to hear them!)
I don't think we can really hold it against Middle Cat (even though she does NOT have amazingly odorless pee), because after all, she is sixteen. She does pretty darn well for her age. Plus, we do have three cats in a relatively small space, sharing one box, which we clean twice a day, but it's not the best arrangement. We never meant to have three cats, but when we got Youngest Cat, we lived in a three-bedroom house with a big basement, where we put two litterboxes, so it worked out just great. I think one cat per bedroom is a decent ratio. Even in Former College City, our really big one-bedroom had room for two litterboxes (in the ginormous bathroom). We just don't have that room here, and we're moving somewhere even SMALLER. (I know, we're brilliant - but it's just so pretty!)
All of these things lead us to consider going cat-less for a while when our current beasts are no longer with us. Eldest Cat is 17 and Middle Cat is 16, so realistically, they won't be around too much longer. (Though I am in denial about this.) Youngest Cat is much younger (nearly 7), but he's feline leukemia positive, so we don't know if he'll live a full cat life or not. Even if he does, since he is FeL+, it'll be hard to get another cat - a kitten would be too susceptible to the disease, and introducing an adult cat is much harder. (Though we might have to try it to give him someone to torment, and to prevent him from destroying the apartment.)
But the idea of not having one of these lovely creatures around is pretty sad, I have to say. As I grow more and more selfish in my old age, the idea of not having to clean a litterbox, medicate a cat twice a day, deal with yucky cat food, or wake up in the middle of the night (or worse, 45 minutes before the alarm) to the importunings of a bored or hungry cat is appealing. But I can say that, now, while Youngest Cat curls up at the other end of the couch, and Middle Cat wanders into the bathroom to sit under the bathtub faucet, waiting for someone to turn it on for her. I'm not sure I could say that when I keep expecting to see furry faces around the hallway corner, only to find no one there.