You knew I had to do it... it's a meme! about pseudonymity! (from jo(e))
Is your blogging persona more serious than your real life persona? I don't know. Real life professional persona, or personal persona? I consider my blog relatively serious, but I've had people call it funny, too. I'm often boringly serious in real life (in the classroom, students frequently have to tell me when they're joking). My blog persona certainly isn't any more formal than my real life persona - I think of my blog as very casual, unlike the careful prose I write for academic publication. It's pretty much like the me sitting around debating the meaning of life with my friends.
Do you think the only safe way an academic can write publicly is to write anonymously?
No. It completely depends on what you're trying to accomplish with your blog. If you're writing in a purely professional vein, about areas connected to your research, names are great. Or even if you're not, and you want to write under your name, that's great. I think there are things that one can write under their own name that could be detrimental to one's career, but that doesn't mean that writing under your own name will necessarily hurt your career. There are LOTS of ways you can tank a career, if you try hard enough!
Do you think that your blog could ruin your career? I don't know; I feel like that's outside my control, and depends on the reactions of other people. At the moment, yes, my career success does depend on how others see me (and, of course, what I do to shape that, though I'm not convinced that what I do always matches up exactly with how others see me), and who knows whether someone might be offended by something I've written? I try not to write a blog that could ruin my career! I try to write something that I can be proud of. If something I'm proud of actually did ruin my career, it's probably not a career I want. More pragmatically, I try to avoid writing things that could reasonably piss off my department and college. So I'd be surprised if this blog could ruin my career; but I was surprised when a good friend of mine got fired for her blog, too!
Do you use a pseudonym out of fear? I don't think of it as fear - I think of it as a desire for boundaries, and control over what gets associated with my professional persona. Face it, I talk a great deal about academia here, and if I wrote under my real name, it would be legitimate for these musings to be associated with my professional persona. But while I stand behind what I say here, again, I don't consider this a formal academic document that I want chalked up to my tenure review. I consider this shooting the breeze with friends/colleagues. Because so many of my friends are academics, and because academia is the kind of job that permeates your whole life, it's something I talk about a lot. But I don't think a transcript of me sitting in a bar talking about my job should be part of my tenure package. Nor do I want my posts on shoes to be part of my tenure package! But I want to be able to talk about shoes if I feel like it. And yes, I'm sure some people will see my desire to separate these things as a result of fear. Like I said, I'd call it a desire to control my professional image. And maybe caution - a caution which, I'd argue, younger women faculty have every reason to feel.
What is the biggest drawback to writing pseudonymously? Well, when I say things that people do speak approvingly of, the "real" me wants credit! There are some things I write here that I think would be very appropriately considered as part of my professional service. But oh well, I can't have it both ways. I guess the only other problem is that because I don't openly identify where I live, for instance, I might miss out on some potential blogger meet-ups. (Oh, and the fact that there are some people who seem convinced that writing pseudonymously is less valid than writing under a name because I'm not willing to stand behind what I say, or something. Whatever. I'm not usually moving in those online circles, so it's not a big deal.)
Has anyone stumbled on your blog and found it accidentally?
Not that I'm aware of. I did see some hits from my college's server recently that I was pretty confident weren't me, but they don't seem to have reappeared. I don't think it would be hard to recognize me, since most people who know me know I have a long-distance marriage and three cats!
Have you outed yourself to any other bloggers? Yes, I tend to out myself pretty readily if I have any e-mail correspondence with someone. I feel like if I'm going to deal with someone one-on-one, it's probably polite to let them know who I am. (Though this mostly applies if I contact them, rather than the other way around!)
Has your blog allowed you to experiment with writing? The form of my writing isn't in the least experimental. Blogging has provided me an opportunity to write in a non-academic way, which I used to do a lot, so I appreciate that. The closest I've come to "experimenting" here is very occasionally I write something I'd call creative non-fiction. I enjoy writing those posts and wouldn't get the chance to do so otherwise. So I guess I'm experimenting, for me, but what I produce isn't experimental in the grand scheme of writing.
Why do you use a pseudonym? See above, under whether I use a pseudonym out of fear. I will agree with people who've mentioned it as a convention of this particular blogging community; I wanted to join in that community, and since everyone else was using a pseudonym (at this point it was Dr. Crazy, profgrrrrl, Bitch Ph.D., Mel at In Favor of Thinking, and Anbruch in his former incarnation at the Cul-de-Sac), I think part of me felt it would be jarring to just bust into that group under my real name. But some of the very first discussions I read were about using pseudonyms, and the practice made sense to me.
And I like jo(e)'s final point about this so much, I'm going to reproduce it here:
I think that is the main thing that writing pseudonymously does – it
limits my audience to other bloggers. Students, family, colleagues, or
real life friends cannot find my blog by searching for my name.
Bloggers come to my blog via a blogroll or a comment I’ve left on a
blog. That way, my readers are bloggers who understand the conventions
of blogging. They understand that posts are written quickly, often
rough drafts and unfinished thoughts. For the most part, they know the
blogs that I link to, and can see what I write as part of a larger
conversation in a blogging community. I don’t have to explain what a
meme is, or explain why I might post a photo of a cat on a Friday.
Pseudonymous bloggers write for other bloggers. That seems to piss off
people outside the blogging community. I think they are jealous.
I will add that I certainly don't expect my blog to be limited to a set group of people or that I don't welcome anyone here who's interested. This isn't a private space - it's out on the big wide internets, and I fully recognize that. But it does help to be speaking within the conventions of a community (even one that's incredibly diverse and by no means willing to agree with everything I say!).
Finally, jo(e), being ever gracious, didn't tag people. And this isn't really a taggable meme - anyone who's interested should, as always, participate. But since I mentioned a group of bloggers above who were around when I started and got me interested in this whole thing: I'd love to see what Dr. Crazy, profgrrrrl, Bitch Ph.D., Mel, and Anbruch have to say on the subject.
Postscript: You may be sick of this subject by now, but guess what? This post is a HUGE improvement on the woe-is-me-a-long-distance-marriage-sucks post that I was toying with last night. So be grateful that I find pseudonymity fascinating!